Pages

Showing posts with label Haredim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Haredim. Show all posts

Monday, March 22, 2010

Avigdor Lieberman Continues to Sell Out to the Haredim

Residents of Israel's south have unfortunately been under siege from rockets from Gaza for years and years. A new hospital wing in Ashkelon was planned to be built to be rocket and missile proof, but human bones were found there.

Apparently, United Torah Judaism via (the handlers of) Yosef Shalom Elyashiv has decided that, despite what archaeologists say (that they are Christian or pagan bones) and despite pikuach nefesh, this 90 million NIS ($24 million) wing must be stopped.

Instead, according to MK Yaakov Litzman, they must spent an additional 100 million NIS, more than doubling the price and delaying construction of the facility by 18 months.

5 (or 16 including Shas) MKs apparently are enough to force this, thanks to the help of other coalition members.

An 11-10 cabinet vote approved this disgraceful change.

In opposition were most (perhaps all that voted) Labor ministers, as well as 6 Likud ministers (Yuli Edelstein, Yossi Peled, Michael Eitan, Dan Meridor, Gideon Sa'ar, and Limor Livnat).

Lieberman cast the deciding vote in favor (and two of his fellow Beitenu members abstained; had they voted no, it would also have killed it).

So he's sold out completely on secularism (or even sanity), and has been the PA's best diplomat as foreign minister. How I hope his party goes down next election.

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Lox not kosher? Rabbi (Moshe) Karp urges Ban on Salmon

I keep thinking eventually I will not be shocked by the insanity of the ultra-Orthodox, but I keep getting proven wrong.

There is probably no food more associated with (Ashkenazi) Judaism than lox. The very word lox came into American English from לאקס
in Yiddish, the word for salmon, which our ancestors have eaten since living in Eastern Europe.

Now Rabbi Moshe Karp (yeah, you'd think it's a joke, but this guy exists), the Rabbi of the ultra-Orthodox West Bank settlement Modi'in Illit, has ruled that halibut, salmon, flounder and various other fish can no longer be considered kosher, because the roundworm anisakis parasite lives in these fish.

The thing is, the Gemara mentions this (Chullin 67b),
תולעים דרני דבשרא אסירי דכוורי שריין

which means (after looking up all but the third and fourth words in Rav Marcus Jastrow's Talmudic dictionary) Parasitic worms are prohibited in meat (i.e. mammal meat and perhaps poultry) but permitted in fish. According to Dovid Bistricer of the Orthodox Union, the Shulchan Aruch and rishonim say the following:

Mature insects swallowed by fish are considered sheratzei hayam and are prohibited, while insects grown inside the flesh are not considered sheratzei hayam and are permitted until they exit the fish into the ocean. Although the Rambam (Hilchos Ma’achalos Assuros 2:17) makes a distinction between insects grown inside flesh while the fish is alive and while it is not, the position of all other rishonim is that insects grown inside the flesh of fish are permitted even when the fish is alive. The Shulchan Aruch Yoreh Deah (84:16) rules clearly that all insects found in the bellies of fish are prohibited, while those found in the flesh are permitted.


According to the Center for Disease Control, the anisakis does not reach mature form until after its fish host is eaten by a marine mammal (or a human if improperly cooked)

Yet Karp makes the outlandish claim that new scientific evidence says otherwise:

According to the OU’s Rabbi Goldberg, at the end of the meeting in Brooklyn, a chassidishe rebbe in attendance asked Karp if he was implying that gedolim of yore ate treif. Rabbi Goldberg said that Karp explained, “they did not know what we know and that the fish is assur (forbidden) because we know how the bug works.”

“I asked him to please tell me the name of the Jew or gentile that clarified it for us and where is this research, and when was it put out,” recalled Rabbi Goldberg. He believes the idea of a ban will soon be sleeping with the fishes. “If you say something is based on science then you have to provide the science.

Now, never mind that Rabbi Moshe Feinstein wouldn't even write a teshuva on this because he felt the Shulchan Aruch had already fully answered it. Never mind that whenever science says something about the age of the Earth, causes of earthquakes, etc., Haredim always condemn the science in favor of what Chazal (the sages who wrote the Mishna and Gemara) said. Looks like the Haredim in Israel are going for it , and the ones in Monsey and Lakewood will follow. One hopes the Orthodox Union at least continues to have more sense than this.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Who Funds Aaron Feinhandler's Computer-Smashing Machane Yisrael Yeshiva?

I don't know how many people have seen the footage of this "ceremony" that took place at the Machane Yisrael Yeshiva (ישיבת מחנה ישראל) in the Beit Yisrael section of Jerusalem.



Yeah, that's right, the Rabbi, Aaron Feinhandler (אהרן פינהנדלר), is (with protective eyewear) smashing a perfectly functional PC, after which the yeshiva students all jump on it to further destroy it beyond repair in a ritual seeming like a cross between drunken frat boy antics and a good, old-fashioned book-burning. The yeshiva is oriented towards ba'al teshuvas (those born Jewish but not born/raised Orthodox/ultra-Orthodox who have embraced that lifestyle). He is talking about how computers are in general not kosher, and how the destruction is intended to be some kind of a healing process for the treyf of the computer that had belonged to one of the ba'al teshuvas.

And lest people think that this was just a stunt pulled in the spirit of Purim and the month of Adar, Vos iz Neias contacted Rabbi Feinhandler and, in an exceedingly disturbing interview, he makes it clear that it was done entirely in earnest and that computers are pure evil.

Some choice excerpts:

On the Internet you see women without their hair covered ... The reason we send our children to chareidi chinuch (education) is because we want to keep out everything that is out there. ... This is the 3rd time we've shattered a computer. The first computer we broke was a $1,000 computer ... Our boys visit homes voluntarily to try to get people to remove their computers

Perhaps the most twisted part was about the guy who had owned the computer being smashed in the video.

The computer we broke this time belonged to a photographer. He used his computer to develop his pictures, but then he realized it was causing him to fall spiritually. He decided he's better off taking pictures with a camera and then he'll develop the film in a photo shop.

Note to the rabbi. You cannot remove the 'untzius' elements that may have gotten into your photo if you "develop the film in a photo shop". But you can do that easily with Photoshop.

Needless to say, 'unkosher' cellphones and home computers are prohibited for anyone attending the yeshiva, and they will not marry off anyone who doesn't promise not to use computers.

He gave an interesting answer to "computers for work" question:

They need to work on the Internet for their parnossa? It's better to clean streets and dirty your body than to work on the Internet and dirty your soul.

Of course, few to no Haredim do those jobs either. Feinhandler certainly doesn't. Which leads to the question: Where does he get his funding from?

From the American government (via tax-exempt status), for one:

An article from Aish HaTorah's website, somewhat ironically, gives more details about who may be enabling this terrible yeshiva with funding, by providing addresses for "charitable donations" both in the U.S. and Canada.

Machane Yisrael.
9 Leib Str.
P.O Box 5666,
Beit Yisrael,
Jerusalem, Israel.
Tel: 972-2-537-0290
Fax: 972-2-537-4224

For charitable Donations:

CANADA:

Press Foundation
ATTENTION OF MACHANE YISRAEL
P.O. Box 19
Station T,
Toronto, Ontario, Canada

USA:

To: American Friends of Machane Israel,
c/o: Gotlieb,
4901 - 18th Ave, Brooklyn NY, 11204.
Tel: 718 - 436 7826

I'm going to do some searching and post another post (which I'll link to) once I've found out more.

Saturday, February 13, 2010

They're Throwing Iron Rods at Police Now?

Haredi riots reach a new level (unless they've been throwing iron rods for a while and I just missed it).

Police forces were called to the scene and began dispersing the protesters who set garbage bins on fire and threw iron rods at police officers.

Why didn't the police respond in kind? (or at least with rubber bullets)

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Invasion of the (Haredi) Body Snatchers

Man, things are just getting crazier and crazier among Jerusalem's Haredim. Things have literally reached body snatching. No joke.

A lady in her 20s was found dead in an abandoned building in (where else?) Mea Shearim. That's when things went nutty

A police car was dispatched to the area as well, and an initial investigation revealed that the death was likely not the result of a criminal incident.

But the affair did not end there. Dozens of haredim arrived in the area and, according to the police, began assaulting the policemen, caused damage to their car, grabbed the body and escaped. Additional police forces were dispatched to the area to help locate the corpse.

Eventually, the body was recovered with the help of the ZAKA rescue unit under condition that no autopsy be performed (autopsies are, with limited exceptions, prhobited in traditional Judaism as desecrating the dead; for more on this see here or here (Chabad should be in line with everyone else on this, the Rebbe aside). ZAKA, of course, are the true tzaddiks who a few weeks ago were saving lives in Haiti.

Of course, ZAKA didn't come out of it unscathed; ZAKA Jerusalem leader Bentzi Oring was beaten on his way in to try to negotiate things out, a major chillul Hashem.

The paramedic who was present when the body was taken really does have a dystopian sci-fiesque story:

"[The policeman] said he was hit in the face, pushed down and that the corpse was snatched on a stretcher. I looked outside and saw a stretcher march of 30 haredim running with a covered body. They shouted, 'The daughters of Israel will not be deserted.'"

According to the paramedic, "It was a well planned operation."

The Haredi news site Behadrei Haredim has their version of the story and an update. What's worth noting is the clear attempt there to distance the broader Haredi community from the קנאים (zealots) who pulled this.

They also have pictures of the police and some of the protestors. One interesting thing is the presence of at least two dark-skinned police officers, presumably Ethiopian Jews since I think they are a bit too dark to be Yemenite (I could be wrong, though). Either way, I liked seeing that.

The lady of blessed memory whose corpse caused this whole thing apparently had head surgery several weeks ago, and on the advice of her father, took too many painkillers, resulting in her death.

Sunday, January 10, 2010

Haredim Should Do the Jobs 'Israelis Won't Do' Instead of East Asians

Ha'aretz, in a story about the rejection of a citizenship process request for a (past childbirth age, for what that is worth) Filipina woman so she could stay with her Israeli partner, dropped this bombshell:

A document obtained by Haaretz reveals that the decision reflects a trend of trying to prevent marriages between Israelis and Filipinas.

"Too many Filipinas are going this road. It must stop and they must be removed from the country," the document states.

Before the second intifada, a lot of menial jobs in Israel were done by Palestinians (not all of them, but a good number; obviously Jews did some and Arab Israelis did some as well). One of my memories from living in Israel (on Antigonus Street in Jerusalem) in 1997 was that the groundskeeper was Palestinian. I remember this primarily in the context that he could not come to work for a few weeks after the Mahane Yehuda suicide bombing.

After the second intifada began, Palestinians were (not unjustifiably) deemed to be a security threat, and so it became far harder for Palestinians to work in Israel, though many West Bank Palestinians still do. As a result, there was a menial labor shortage, and Israel began importing East Asian "guest workers" (Thai, Vietnamese, Filipino). Since Shas head Eli Yishai became Minister of the Interior (which controls immigration policy, among other things), he's been pushing for deportation of children of workers who were born in Israel, and of course this latest memo, among other things.

Levi Brackman, a Haredi (I believe Chabad) rabbi from Colorado, notes that Haredim are contemplating selling kidneys to pay for his daughter and her husband-to-be to have an apartment so her husband could study Torah.

This is in fact what the great sages of old wanted when they said that the study of Torah must be accompanied by working at a trade or business to make a living (Ethics of the Fathers 2:2).


Rabbinic leadership is needed on the highest level to change a system that is forcing many in their communities to take desperate steps just to cover their families’ basic needs.

...

this does not exempt the haredi community from learning a profession or vocation so that they can become productive members of society. Many more haredi professional and vocational schools need to be developed and the societal pressure to become a full time Torah scholar or a teacher needs to be removed.

Of course, there are plenty of jobs in Israel which the (secular/professionally useful) education-lacking Haredim can do.

Agriculture would allow them to fulfill a whole bunch of mitzvot, and can be done in a perfectly tzniut way in today's world. Ditto for caregiving; they'd just work only with the same sex. As for construction; if Rabbi Hillel could be a carpenter, they can do construction work.

Oh, how I wish someone would propose this to Yishai. I'd love to see his reaction.

Saturday, January 9, 2010

An Open Letter to Jonathan Rosenblum

Rav Rosenblum,

I read with great interest your recent article in the Jerusalem Post entitled, A Question of Governance, and I think you brought up some good points about the problems facing the Israeli economy. However, I'm wondering why you didn't delve just a little bit further into the data on the Israeli educational system.

The data from the latest Statistical Abstract of Israel seem to show that the problems in the educational system are not equally distributed.

For instance, take a look at Table 8.23, which lists the total number of students in 12th grade, how many took the bagrut exam, how many passed the bagrut exam and how many met the entrance requirements for university. There are three groups of students of whom over 50% of the 12th grade classes meet the university entrance requirements. These are Jewish students educated at state secular schools (general) [55.5%], Jewish students educated at state religious schools (Administration of Religious Education) [54.0%], and Arab Christian students [53.1%].

Now, I am not saying these numbers are terrific. The American Jewish Committee has estimated in their yearbooks (go to ajcarchives.org and download the most recent one there) that 94% of American Jews over the age of 25 have a bachelor's degree. Of course, the United States does not have exams similar to the bagrut. However, American Jews tend to do quite well on the SAT and the ACT. If you look at the list of candidates for the Presidential Scholar's Program from 2005 (the year I graduated), an award for which extremely high SAT and ACT scores determine eligibility, a highly disproportionate number are probably Jewish based on their surnames. It is especially impressive since they set the qualification bar by state to try to equalize the number of students receiving the award in each state. This puts Jews at a disadvantage, 2/3 of American Jews live in one of the 6 largest states (which make up 40% of the total population of the country) and 93% live in one of the 20 largest states (which make up 74% of the total population of the country). And it is not just "secular/assimilated Jews"; a striking 3 of the 40 or so people who were in my grade at Solomon Schechter Day School of the Raritan Valley made the cut. So to summarize, yes, Israeli students from these sectors could do better, but it's not that bad. After all, only 27% of Americans as a whole over 25 have a bachelor's degree (though that's arguably a problem for America, which is another story entirely).

However, only 31% of Muslim 12th graders and 37.1% of Druze 12th graders meet eligibility requirements for university. And only 22.7% of ultra-Orthodox 12th graders even took the bagrut exams, and a miniscule 4.7% of them met the requirements to enter university.

And it is worse than that, as not all students in the Arab sector or the ultra-Orthodox sector make it as far as 12th grade. According to Table 8.31, 7.6% of ultra-Orthodox students drop out yearly between 7th and 12th grades, as do 5% of Arab students (but only 2.1% of state secular and state religious students)

Given that the Arab sectors (in particular the Muslim Arab sector) and the ultra-Orthodox sectors have much higher birth rates than the rest of the population, these disparities may have already been responsible for the poor overall numbers mentioned in your column. More importantly, because of the high birth rates, things overall will presumably get worse if the poor performances in these sectors is not addressed.

So, to make a long story short: is there a reason as to why you left these huge disparities out? And what do you think is causing them? And what should be done about it?

Thanks in advance.

Friday, January 8, 2010

Are Haredim Planning to Expand their Shabbos rioting?

Apparently so, according to this; they're going after anything else that's happening on Shabbat

In other shabbos matters, the head of the Vaad L’maan Shabbos, Rabbi Yosef Rosenfeld, has prepared a list of food stores opening operating on shabbos, in gas stations in the capital. Addressing a vaad meeting, the rav called on members to address this alarming reality as well as to prepare a list of stores operating in the city on shabbos, trampling the kedusha of the day

Monday, December 28, 2009

The Haredi Pyramid Scheme

One interesting question about the Haredim is how they pay to live, given that so few of them work.

Apparently a pyramid scheme has been going on for a while

Few people know about the pyramids of haredi (ultra-orthodox) free-loan societies (Gma"chim), charitable funds which do not necessarily rely on generosity of donors (whose numbers have diminished in the past couple of years), but which answer the question: how do haredim pay for the apartments that they buy for their large numbers of children.

To obtain money (tens of thousands of dollars) from a free-loan society, partly as a loan and partly as a grant, the average haredi borrower puts aside a much smaller sum (a few dozen dollars) toward the free-loan society when a child is born or shortly thereafter. In this way, money coming in from young parents immediately goes out to older parents who have to marry off a child. With the haredi population's impressive growth rate (about 6% per year) the model has worked marvelously as the pyramid has a growing base.

Of course, all pyramid schemes eventually fail, and the people at the base really get it socked to them. According to the people over at Vos iz Neias, the s**t is about to hit the fan here, thanks to the convergence of a whole bunch of factors. These factors include:

  1. Child Allowance Cuts-The last time the non-Haredi public rebelled was in the 2003 elections, giving 15 seats to the secularist Shinui party. One of the biggest measures they got done was on the financial side in terms of child allowances. See, before May 2003, the government gave far, far larger allowances per child to those families with more children. These families were pretty much all either ultra-Orthodox or Arab. However, whoever it was, this was still an obscene policy. Back in 2003 before the initial cuts, a family with one or two children got 146 Shekels (at the time, about $30) in child allowances per child per month. A family with 8 children, however, got 508 shekels (at the time about $106) per child per month. The law has gradually phased that out. Today, any additional child born after 2003 causes a family to get a flat additional 159 shekels per month, while the rate increases for pre-2003 births have flattened.
    This hurts the Haredi pyramid scheme on two levels.
    • Less Money Coming In-Of course, they could start working (and will have to do that or starve eventually), but that hasn't had that much of an increase yet; the result is less available cash
    • A decrease in birth rates-Mind, they are still very high, because they still refuse to use birth control or condoms or abstain from sex, their reading of the Oral and Written Torah forbidding such things. However, the number who work is still quite low. Only about 40% of those between 20 and 60 in Beitar Illit and Modi'in Illit, two ultra-Orthodox cities right across the Green Line in the West Bank. In Hadera, a secular city, over 80% of those between 20 and 60 work. And 30% of Haredi men work; the women work in addition to dealing with all of the kids. Mind you, the growth rate is still EXTREMELY high. The Bank of Israel's recent study on fertility and child allowances found that ultra-Orthodox women had a fertility rate of 7.5 in 1996-1999, 7.24 in 2001-2002, and (after the allowance decreases) 6.74 in 2006-2007.

      Mind you, my own Jewish great-great-grandparents back in the old country (although all my great-grandparents were born in Europe [one in France, though his parents were born in the Pale, and the other 7 in the Pale of Settlement] I believe a few of them had more children here) also had a very large number of children, at least the four who I know for sure brought their entire families over here. But that's for another post, and at any rate, back when they were born, it was not always clear how many children would survive, and of course the world was less populated. Also, they all worked for a living, or at least one of them did.
  2. The Economic Crisis-Since some of course do work, it's hitting Haredim as well, and those ones have less to give communally
  3. Housing Prices-Housing Prices in many places are high


Anyway, apparently it's coming to a head now.
It is good that it is happening now, because the longer it takes to occur, the more screwed the state of Israel will be.

Saturday, December 26, 2009

Haredim Stone a Car in Jerusalem

Now, of course, that sort of thing has been going on for a long, long time in Haredi neighborhoods on Shabbos. Certainly I remember hearing plenty about it when I was in Israel from June-August 1997.

Ramot neighborhood, Jerusalem;

Of course, that doesn't make it any more acceptable.

Wednesday, December 23, 2009

Residents of Immanuel settlement unaware of Barack Obama's existence

At least I have to assume so, based on this quote from a resident:
"No court ruling or Education Ministry decision can bring the two groups together," an Immanuel resident said Wednesday.
"It's like putting Americans and Africans together. They can't study together with such huge mental differences,"

Of course, American Stanley Ann Dunham and African Barack Hussein Obama did, in fact, study together at the University of Hawaii back in the early 1960s, as that is where they met, and as a result, our 44th president was conceived and born (in whatever country the Birthers are currently claiming, of course). On the other hand, I guess what they were doing wasn't exactly studying, so maybe the resident was making a sly joke.

I doubt it, though. After all, the settlement in question, Immanuel, is an all-Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) settlement located deep in the West Bank; as such, unlike the huge Beitar Illit and Modi'in Illit right on the border, it hasn't grown rapidly. In fact, unlike the West Bank as a whole, it has the same population it had 18 years ago. The "two groups" mentioned here are ultra-Orthodox Ashkenazi girls and ultra-Orthodox Sephardi girls.

This controversy (or, as the Ashkenazi Haredim would say, cawnsroyversy) has been going for several years, every since the Bais Yaakov/Beit Yaakov created "two schools under one roof" in 2007 by separating the Ashkenazi and Sephardi schoolgirls.

A lawsuit was filed early on, at the behest of the residents, because it was not (just like it never is) "separate but equal"

Elyashiv Aharon, deputy chairman of the United Council of Sephardi Communities in Emmanuel, said that while the town's Sephardi residents would prefer that their children study with the Ashkenazi pupils, they were not opposed in principle to segregation.

"But the way it was done was brutal," said Aharon. "They gave Sephardi girls the impression that they were second-rate human beings. Girls came home from school crying. It was a trauma that is liable to have a lasting impact on those girls' lives."

In 2008, there were threats that the school would lose its license, but they were never followed through.

More recently, the government has been more active in trying to integrate the school. As a result, a whole bunch of the Ashkenazi girls have been skipping schools. Mind you, the Bais Yaakov schools in Israel teach precious little useful (i.e. secular) information anyway, so it's not such a big loss.

However, the entire thing is really disgusting, even for Haredim. We're all Jews, after all. Jeez, maybe they should use those soldiers who don't want to expel Jews from the settlements to instead forcibly integrate the school a la the American South.

Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Conversion-revoking Haredi Rabbi Leib Tropper Has Affair with Shiksa!

Mind, she was in the process of converting to Judaism, but it's still pretty hilarious.

Rabbi Leib Tropper sex-tape hottie-sharing

Or, for the original scoop, Scott/Shmarya Rosenberg of the Failed Messiah blog, well-known for his coverage of the Rubashkin trial:

There are five tapes, which can be listened to on Youtube. The first one is here:




Part 2, Part 3, Part 4, Part 5

A woman in the process of converting to Judaism told FailedMessiah.com that a well known and powerful ultra-Orthodox rabbi who supervises conversions worldwide asked her for sexual favors in return for completing her conversion. The woman alleges the rabbi, Leib Tropper, founder of Eternal Jewish Family, arranged sexual encounters between her and and his wife – encounters Tropper watched. She also alleges Tropper asked her to engage in sexual encounters and have phone sex with other men.

This of course is extremely assur, since Tropper is presumably married.

Unfortunately, the lady in question, Shannon Orand, does not seem to have been dissuaded from conversion.

I say unfortunately because of the type of person she seems to be from her Myspace page.

Heroes The religious Zioniists who put their life on the line everyday to keep God's land holy, and Jewish.

It's chutzpah for a shiksa whose ancestors (recent according to her own page and possibly less recent depending on exactly where in Europe her forefathers are from) spent their time harassing Jews ... to be pretending to be a Jewish nationalist.

But whatever.